The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Happily Wrathful]

is this fair? Thanks

got this bid too

just got this new bid, is it fair? Thanks

Been trying to get an answer for nearly 5 days 🥲

hi i answered the last trade. no its not fair its worth only 300c$
only two of those items arnt free and worth at most 5c$ each

Is this a fair trade?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111369915&userid=290227&signature=5ImmV6KjtNrMTahyzrs-lw

⭐ August PPS ⭐ - ~1 Non (RR) ⭐ NOTE: This pet is currently having a demand spike.⭐

Kitsunes === Range 2.5 to 3 MA
theres three, at max value thats 90 old rares already almost 1 non but at lowest its 75

Cheshire Cat === 0.5 Non or 50 old rares
these alone already go over 1 non
1 non is 100 old rares

corgi 1.5 MA or 15 old rares

Koi dogs === 0.5MA
20 old rares

all of these at lowest add up to 160 old rares or 1.6nons

at highest this adds up to 175 old rares or a little over 1.7nons

im not sure what the demand spike is going for but the pet is a re-release so im not sure if i would accept 1.6nons for it
get another opinion on what its going for atm

link
Does this look ok? They are saying a true date roadkill pony is going for 3 MA but I am not sure if that is true, thank you so much!
I am very out of date with list trades

heya! i dont know where they are getting 3MAs from, horrors list says 1MA i seriously doubt a true date makes it 20 extra rares
your store pet alone is worth 2MA
personally i would not accept this trade at all

Opinions?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111375387&userid=868350&signature=vLFrkFp7-zstf_n3IGKnmw

I would say not fair to you, but since I don't know the demand of them maybe get a second opinion

The rat used to trade for 1MA and had big demand at one point, but I don't think that's the case anymore. And even with that, the rest of the pets can't possibly cover the rest of your side

i would like to mention that the animal egg might be worth something but honestly unless you are looking to collect them i wouldnt trade for them unless they are the popular ones. i dont know about animal egg 8 i cant really find anything on it

your whole side equals 1.1MA

the rat CAN get 1MA as it has okay demand but it is a rerelease which can be spotty. overall your pets have far more demand
and unless you are looking for the rat it will be much harder to trade off

[Its-me-renmimi]

Hi! I'm not at all familiar with the rough C$ going prices for pets, does this trade look good to take?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111369970&userid=715109&signature=uk__6Npaf7hzIUeQmyQfFA

[BillyBoi]

Hey guys I have 2 trade I need help with! I’m having a hard time counting these 2 up, first one was edited to include more and the second trade has 2 additions to it, any help is appreciated greatly! Thank you

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111350777&userid=1017560&signature=v9gbmf9rFVz9yRJf1StnFA


trades/viewtrade.php?id=111314546&userid=1017560&signature=cNqOYCogopquJClTcfeF0w + addition + addition

I need some help with these bulk trades^.^

^

[BlankRedColor]

is this fair?


trades/viewtrade.php?id=111373963&userid=182352&signature=YbxueYWUu7Xe7dNnxGckEA

[catavamp]

Would this be a fair bid for my foxes just counting the items as most of the pets are no longer needed?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111283620&userid=547698&signature=aOfjUjBAdLdmC7DAf4cOlw

[casper.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111376164&userid=833406&signature=8GiqSpXzG4zqNvpzmbc14Q


i’m really really tempted !! how does this look ??

[TooSpooky]

is this fair? Thanks

got this bid too
L]

Been trying to get an answer for nearly 5 days

[causticsugar]

looking for help with assessing the fairness of this trade for a 2013 vr werewolf!

[Happily Wrathful]

Would this be a fair bid for my foxes just counting the items as most of the pets are no longer needed?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111283620&userid=547698&signature=aOfjUjBAdLdmC7DAf4cOlw

hey im not sure about the other items but the first six add up to .6ma

the foxes are fluctuating in demand rn but if you want those items id say its an alright deal, they are all very popular items

[BillyBoi]

is this fair? Thanks

got this bid too
L]

Been trying to get an answer for nearly 5 days

According to Horrors guide the 2012 Alien Store dogs go for 1MA and the Malk Elemental cats go for around 1MA as demand has raised their worth, the foxes I’d say is good faith to make sure it’s equal as the elemental is a RR (RR value seems to be a bit lower but that’s only based on what people will pay for them, it’s up to you and your partner to decide if your RR is being valued the same or a little under the RegRelease value) but all in all I’d say it’s fair (I’d get a second opinion just incase demand has changed)