The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[deerteeth.]

Trade
Im not the best with rarity, any help would be greatly appreciated

edit/add:
Trade 2
This one Im confused about. I asked for 4 2010 bats assuming the 2:1 rule and that a 2009 VR = 2 2009 R. And they gave this back? Is this fair?

From my knowledge, no this is not fair for you. Sitting cats always have a higher demand than bats, and it is a way older VR.

[deerteeth.]

I have no idea what the demand for this horse is.

Thank you for any and all help!

Since it is still unknown rarity it usually goes for ++ it's rarity or date type. This would be overpaying on their end, but it is typical to see this when there are new pets with unknown rarities

haiii everybody !! Are these a fair trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111191914&userid=1100664&signature=6JjBqXjEXOInL0JFcycnhQ

This would be a fair trade imo, staff pets go slightly higher so they /could/ add something small but in my eyes it is fair.

[Rakshah]

I have no clues about the rarity of anything in here.. can someone please help?
Pancake vs. apple

[ROX.mp4]

I have no clues about the rarity of anything in here.. can someone please help?
Pancake vs. apple

from memory, this is unfair. I think the pancakes right now are literally triple (ish) the value of the apple. Please dont take this trade until you get another opinion because I'm not all too sure on how big of a difference there is, but I know that this is extremely unfair to you

edit: not sure how much the apple goes for since I think its TD? but im sure its not the same as the pancakes value

[squeegi]

I have no clues about the rarity of anything in here.. can someone please help?
Pancake vs. apple

pancake goes for 1-1.5 non, apple only goes for .25 non! unfair to the pancakes. even being a true date, the apple would only maybe be worth around .5 non, which is still quite under.

[0tt3r]

hi, im unsure about this trade, if its unfair, how could i make it more fair?

[Iseul]

I have yet another 2 that I'm unsure about. It's been sooo long since I've played and I'm still trying to understand what these terms ( MA, N, etc ) mean + popular demands. How about these two?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111504814&userid=481109&signature=p4bGzEEDJjLCHmLa5hwbOw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111501709&userid=481109&signature=RFEs23GQHEMX6hV5rL8a8Q

[Crazyclaww]

If I take out the duplicate chickens, is this fair?

[Bludragon76]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111507495&userid=1108201&signature=ue2dzJ6cfgibE6oFUUtusg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111507501&userid=1108201&signature=7zYlYni8OKnaucDJ0-3lKA

Are these fair-? Unsure about the bulk trade and im new to higher value trading on the other

[2kcarat_gold]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111507426&userid=258999&signature=FZkCEBe1xRAPYY1FLF14lA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111507627&userid=258999&signature=IxqCr3DLemkg6YsRsppVfw

trying to figure out fairness for a rose PPS auction
thanks!