The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Wysterinka]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110153617&userid=1067205&signature=qPRtf7q2c449zMs1WW3-bg

I can’t remember if there is a thread for item trades, are any of these items valuable and worth 2 rares?

These items are mainly uncommon of their year, which in this case makes them still more valuable than the 2 new eares together

[Rasputin]

Hey! Is this a fair trade? I don't know anything about items

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110166274&userid=958156&signature=p0E5p2uF81Ja2XTIIMC6ug

[bohnette.]

can anyone weigh in on this?
tempted to accept, but also I'm missing a lot of pets from 2014 and before,
and from 2018-2023, but newer pets seem to be a lot easier to trade for.
so not sure if I should ??

[Wysterinka]

can anyone weigh in on this?
tempted to accept, but also I'm missing a lot of pets from 2014 and before,
and from 2018-2023, but newer pets seem to be a lot easier to trade for.
so not sure if I should ??

I wouldn't if I were you. Your side had lot of older pet and also higher rarity so if you still need some pets from those years it would be wise to swap them first since the newest pets you can get anytime with other new pets or events.

[GhostPants]

If anyone could help me with this =)not sure what the aussie goes for ngl

EDIT; this one too! I know both of them have pretty good demand but im looking for something easy to trade down, would the swap be better for me if i were to trade the PPS dragon down?

@ghostpants

[Nikki6Ashba]

If anyone could help me with this =)not sure what the aussie goes for ngl
@ghostpants

Unfair to you. The manticore pps and the Wonderland bw are both 1 ma, so the aussie is overpay . The blue aussie pps is worth 5-7 old rares

[Fofi:]]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110177136&userid=996739&signature=j_BVae8TmvlA0tjabs6hCg

is this fair? its for an auction

[Candycrystal]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110177137&userid=1097824&signature=aiEgGh3bD-wDx9cGZsMfJQ How does this look? Thank you ^^

[birdiesong]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110177137&userid=1097824&signature=aiEgGh3bD-wDx9cGZsMfJQ How does this look? Thank you ^^

this is unfair to you. following the 2:1 rule their side is worth 4 old rares.

your side is worth 7 old rares (valuing the ‘09 rares as 2 old rares each).

your two ‘09 rares would be a fair swap for their two 2010 VRs in my opinion.

[GhostPants]

Any help with this trade? I know both of them have pretty good demand but im looking for something easy to trade down, would the swap be better for me if i were to trade the PPS dragon down?
EDIT: and this one, thank you

@ghostpants