The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[InfernoSis]

Is this fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111369437&userid=290227&signature=3TlGzlZ5MsKiaKmwUNF0wA

[BillyBoi]

Is this fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111369437&userid=290227&signature=3TlGzlZ5MsKiaKmwUNF0wA

So they’re side has the Gearback Tribal (High Tier 3 worth 5MA)
Green Fronted Holly (High Tier 4 worth 2MA)
Pink Striped September (High Tier 4 worth 2MA)
So I’m total their side reaches 9MA assuming pet demand has stayed the same

The kitsune store pets are valued at 2.5-3MA each! So you’re looking at 10MA for a 2.5 each or 12MA if you can find support of them trading at 3MA each, either way if you’re valuing them lower at the 2.5 their side is still missing 1MA worth to be fair to you! ^.^ I hope this helped!

[dαєnєrчѕ tαrgαrчєn]

Any help on this?

Thanks in advance!

[⋆✰ Dragon ✰⋆]

Looking for help with this trade!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111362257&userid=997302&signature=fdtl7vKXF-vVDtvomis8GQ

[Supreme]

Could anyone help me with this trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111360714&userid=702384&signature=hrPlSD6WersFIOHVYSqxtQ

[TooSpooky]

is this fair? Thanks

got this bid too

just got this new bid, is it fair? Thanks

Been trying to get an answer for nearly 2 days 🥲

[Night Raven]

Is this fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111369437&userid=290227&signature=3TlGzlZ5MsKiaKmwUNF0wA

So they’re side has the Gearback Tribal (High Tier 3 worth 5MA)
Green Fronted Holly (High Tier 4 worth 2MA)
Pink Striped September (High Tier 4 worth 2MA)
So I’m total their side reaches 9MA assuming pet demand has stayed the same

The kitsune store pets are valued at 2.5-3MA each! So you’re looking at 10MA for a 2.5 each or 12MA if you can find support of them trading at 3MA each, either way if you’re valuing them lower at the 2.5 their side is still missing 1MA worth to be fair to you! ^.^ I hope this helped!

I would only add that Pink September is True Date, so it would be around 3MA, making a total of 10MA

[Mikuru Senpai]

I need some help with this one!
Not that good with items c:
X

[screamingrainfrog]

Is this fair?

Thanks in advance for any help! :]

[BillyBoi]

Is this fair?

Thanks in advance for any help! :]

2010 Store Clockwork Bun = 1.5Non
UR S’more (Mid Tier 1) = 1.5Non

I’d say unless you can find evidence supporting higher value trades more recently, (a second opinion might be helpful) but from what I can see on horrors guide it’s a fair swap ^.^