The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[EchothroughDarkness]

Hello, I was wondering if this trade was fair. I'm pretty sure the dog is worth 4-5 old rares as it was never on the list.

Any help here. I'm the other person of the trade.

[Burberry]

Item trade
I am aware that the sun pups are a hard to trade for item, and are valued around 1-1.5MA.
I believe my side is around 1.25 MA but I'm not too sure on the sitting cats value, any help would be appreciated.

[Mikuru Senpai]

Here I am once again
Because I also am bad at storepet trades ;;
Trade 1
Trade 2

[CasualTea]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111387271&userid=1030506&signature=e2n2UapLyebtycwCEdKwSQ

A lot of people seem to want this, is this fair?

I also got this offer

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111388061&userid=1030506&signature=aUj14Xsk8LStYOxYRdIrmg

[EchothroughDarkness]

Here I am once again
Because I also am bad at storepet trades ;;
Trade 1
Trade 2

Both are fair.

Trade 1: Stores are worth a old rares each (4 old rares in total)
Top side is worth 4 old rares plus a 2012 rare++

Trade 2: Stores are worth a old rare each (2 old rares in total)
Top side is worth 2 old rares++
Ponies do have a low demand that's why they added to make it fair.

Just my advice, stores tend to go up in worth over the years but it's up to you if you accept these trades

[natureførest]

would still love some assistance if possible <3

Hiya! I just got this trade for my smiler dog, is this fair? Thank you in advance for any help! <3

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111384464&userid=819780&signature=LkTSMyPWY0PbTR-k_FUhow

....

[KakkyPoo]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111397742&userid=97207&signature=lFqQ910IcBc1ZE1L7MtZTw

Is this fair? I’m thinking yes but just after a second opinion
Thanks ^^

[Mikuru Senpai]

Here I am once again
Because I also am bad at storepet trades ;;
Trade 1
Trade 2

Both are fair.

Trade 1: Stores are worth a old rares each (4 old rares in total)
Top side is worth 4 old rares plus a 2012 rare++

Trade 2: Stores are worth a old rare each (2 old rares in total)
Top side is worth 2 old rares++
Ponies do have a low demand that's why they added to make it fair.

Just my advice, stores tend to go up in worth over the years but it's up to you if you accept these trades

What is considered an "old rare"? I mean a 2010 pet has a different value than a 2008 or 2012.
Thank you for telling me!

[Raire]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111397742&userid=97207&signature=lFqQ910IcBc1ZE1L7MtZTw

Is this fair? I’m thinking yes but just after a second opinion
Thanks ^^

It looks fine to me but maybe just know that the tree may have more demand than the dog. Up to you!

would still love some assistance if possible <3

Hiya! I just got this trade for my smiler dog, is this fair? Thank you in advance for any help! <3

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111384464&userid=819780&signature=LkTSMyPWY0PbTR-k_FUhow

....

I may be wrong but I've seen you post for so long haha so I'll try and help.

I don't think the ERs were on the old list and would place them at .5MAish, making this trade a tiny bit over because of the extra malk dog. I'm guessing they added the malk dog to make up for the very poor demand of the very rare pony + horse, which will be harder to trade if you don't want to keep them.

Ultimately I think it's close to fair and up to you! The grinner is worth 2MA.

Edit: Wait just kidding, that's a true date! Unfair to you. Probably worth closer to 2.5 or more for the right collector. I would ask for more.

Also oops I double posted I am so dumb haha, sorry!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111387271&userid=1030506&signature=e2n2UapLyebtycwCEdKwSQ

A lot of people seem to want this, is this fair?


I also got this offer

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111388061&userid=1030506&signature=aUj14Xsk8LStYOxYRdIrmg

People don't know what the rainbow bwolf is really worth. If you're concerned about trading it you could wait until it gets its rarity. Right now it has good demand as people want to complete their yearly collections.

Unfortunately these are hard trades to answer because the bwolf has no set worth.

[jprspereira]

What is considered an "old rare"? I mean a 2010 pet has a different value than a 2008 or 2012.
Thank you for telling me!

Following Horror's guide, an old rare is any rare from 2010/2011.